Old World Spices & Seasoning, Inc., based in Overland Park, KS, is recalling 8,532 bottles of Lillie’s Q Buffalo Wing Sauce (13.5 oz) because of an undeclared milk allergen, which is not listed as a sub-ingredient of butter or in the “Contains” statement. 

The recall was initiated on March 25, 2025, after the labeling issue was identified. It is classified as a Class II recall, indicating a low risk of serious health consequences, though temporary or reversible effects may occur for individuals with milk allergies. The recall remains ongoing, according to the Food and Drug Administration (FDA). 

The affected product was distributed to distribution centers in Kansas, Florida, New Hampshire, California, Iowa, Georgia, Texas, Colorado, Connecticut, Wisconsin, New York, Washington and Pennsylvania.

Recalled Product:

Lillie’s Q Buffalo Wing Sauce

• Description: 13.5 oz bottles, UPC 810069510972 (individual), 10810069510979 (case)
• Lot Codes and Best By Dates:
  • Lot #002125, Best By JAN/21/2026
  • Lot #002025, Best By JAN/20/2026
  • Lot #005725, Best By FEB/25/2026
• Product Quantity: 8,532 bottles
• Distributed By: Old World Spices & Seasoning, Inc., Overland Park, KS
• Sold In: Distribution centers in KS, FL, NH, CA, IA, GA, TX, CO, CT, WI, NY, WA, PA

Consumers with milk allergies should not consume the recalled buffalo wing sauce and are advised to discard it or return it to the place of purchase. Businesses should stop selling or distributing the affected lots.

about allergen concerns

Undeclared allergens, such as milk, can cause allergic reactions in sensitive individuals, ranging from mild symptoms like hives to severe reactions like anaphylaxis. Though this is a Class II recall with a low probability of severe health outcomes, consumers experiencing adverse effects after consuming the product should seek medical attention promptly.